The UK Dart 15 Association

Club Course Preferences

Dart 15 Chat
Post Reply
Charles
Vice Admiral
Vice Admiral
Posts: 384
Joined: Tue Dec 19, 2006 11:53 pm

Club Course Preferences

Post by Charles »

Hi All

My club runs Sunday racing in the format:-

AM
2 races back to back
Fast fleet windward leeward
Slow fleet round the cans

PM
2 races back to back
Both fleets windward leeward

Sprints are in the slow fleet and there are generally more non-asymetrics racing than asymmetrics.

I understand asymmetrics prefer windward leeward but I find a course without a reach rather lacking in fun so I'd prefer all round the cans courses.

What format do other clubs run? Interested to hear your thoughts.
Charles
1237, Sticks and Stones
1942, Ingrid
Yorkshire Dales SC
God does not deduct from our allotted life span the time spent sailing (or talking, texting, reading, posting to websites & emailing about it)
User avatar
Liam
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 952
Joined: Sat Aug 01, 2009 7:23 am
Location: Isle of Wight
Contact:

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Liam »

We are blessed with not having to pander to half boats so we try and set a course to suit catamarans preferably with all points of wind catered for.
2034 - No Quarter, 1957 - Dreadnought, 1709 - Biscuit
Shanklin Sailing Club
Holder of OTT Shield
9th most improved at 2018 Nationals
User avatar
Bob Carter
Admiral of the Fleet
Admiral of the Fleet
Posts: 1667
Joined: Fri Dec 15, 2006 8:52 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Bob Carter »

Hi Charles,
That looks like too much windward - leeward to me. A Sprint 15 sailed una-rig is slow downwind and as it can go straight downwind it is not very tactical either. In my time as events secretary we avoided it. Nick maintained that going straight downwind also penalised the heavy weight sailors. It is not so bad in Sport mode (or for Dart 18s) as you have to reach and tack downwind. At Grafham only asymmetrical boats sail windward-leeward courses in Club racing. All other boats sail round the cans in all races. The only exception is the Club Championships which sail a mixture of courses but usually only one race is windward- leeward.
Regards
Bob
Brian Phipps
Commodore
Commodore
Posts: 273
Joined: Tue Dec 19, 2006 5:56 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Brian Phipps »

The Sprint 15 and the Dart 18 were designed for all points of sailing including reaching which is the most fun! The old Olympic courses of triangles and sausages was a great compromise, something The Restronquet SC continue to use.
Brian
Jenny Ball
Vice Admiral
Vice Admiral
Posts: 388
Joined: Wed Mar 02, 2016 10:07 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Jenny Ball »

Hi Charles

At Marconi, we are fortunate to have our own fleet start and also our own course. We ask to have round the cans courses, including with reaches, wherever tide and wind direction permit. Our Medium Cat Fleet (primarily Dart 18s) also prefer the same sort of course. Our Fast Cat fleet - (all assymetric) - specifically prefer windward/leeward courses. The Medium and Fast Cats start together to avoid having a very lengthy overall start sequence but they are set separate courses and are finished independently. The monohulls - a mixture of kite and non-kite boats - seem less concerned about their courses - so long as they get a true beat at some point and don't have to hike for hours against the Blackwater tide!

I agree with Brian that the triangle sausage courses can be a good compromise.

Jenny
Brian Phipps
Commodore
Commodore
Posts: 273
Joined: Tue Dec 19, 2006 5:56 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Brian Phipps »

Just a added note , the triangle course section needs to edge towards a 90deg wing mark from the windward or leeward mark ( depending on wind strength) rather than a equilateral triangle which is likely only to deliver 2 x long downwind legs for a boat that tacks down wind.
Brian
User avatar
Bob Carter
Admiral of the Fleet
Admiral of the Fleet
Posts: 1667
Joined: Fri Dec 15, 2006 8:52 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Bob Carter »

Yes, agreed about the Olympic Course but it is more problematic if the Club does average lap time racing as it requires 2 passes of the committee boat to constitute one timed lap. Errors can easily occur. Grafham does predominantly average lap time racing as a wider range of boat speeds can be accommodated in a single start and for this reason the old Olympic course is seldom used except in single class racing.
Regards
Bob
Charles
Vice Admiral
Vice Admiral
Posts: 384
Joined: Tue Dec 19, 2006 11:53 pm

Re: Club Course Preferences

Post by Charles »

Thanks for the feedback Liam, Bob, Brian & Jenny. That's more or less what I expected you to say. The Asy fleet at YDSC seem to hold a bit too much sway, particularly as they usually make up less than half the fleet. It seems rather selfish that they get the fun legs for them but force non-asy boats to miss out on reaches. Although one of the older Laser sailors did comment that he appreciated the rest of windward leeward courses! I'm hoping it's going to be at lease a decade if not two before I join him in that opinion!! :D I'll be monitoring the situation & make a few quiet enquiries about the reasoning for YDSC's course setting.
Charles
1237, Sticks and Stones
1942, Ingrid
Yorkshire Dales SC
God does not deduct from our allotted life span the time spent sailing (or talking, texting, reading, posting to websites & emailing about it)
Post Reply